Home | On The Menu intro  | Reviews | Links |



.........a full-grown horse or dog is beyond comparison a more rational, as well as a more conversable animal, than an infant of a day, or a week, or even a month, old. But suppose they were otherwise, what would it avail? the question is not, Can they reason? nor Can they talk but, Can they suffer?"
Jeremy Bentham (1748 – 1832) Introduction to the Principals of Morals and Legislation



INTRODUCTION

The words ‘factory’ and ‘farming’ were linked together for the first time in the United States of America in 1890. They were used to describe farms which used modern industrial methods to breed and fatten animals so that they produced meat, eggs and milk as quickly as possible in the smallest amount of space.

In Britain factory farming began in earnest in the 1940s as a way of coping with post-war shortages and to guarantee food supply. By the 1950s industrial farming methods were well established. Laying hens had been packed into battery cages; veal calves were shut up alone in dark crates; pigs were crammed together in fetid sheds and forced to lie in their own excrement; poultry was so densely crowded in such huge numbers that their beaks had to be ‘trimmed’ to prevent them harming each other.

The change compared to traditional farming was immense. Traditional farms tended to be small mixed farms where poultry ran around the farmyard, cows grazed in fields and pigs in their sties were fed kitchen slops and harvest left-overs. But the traditional rural order didn’t mean that farm animals were strangers to cruelty. MP Richard Martin had good reason to steer the first anti-cruelty bill through parliament in 1822. For the first time cattle, horses and sheep were given a degree of legal protection. 1824 saw the advent of the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, now the RSPCA. And in 1911 farm animals received further safeguards in the Protection of Animals Act.

For nearly 100 years – from 1911 until 2007 – the 1911 Act was the sole legal instrument which protected farm animals from cruelty. The 1911 law had been drawn up when farming on an industrial scale had scarcely been imagined – when the idea that animals would be kept in windowless sheds under artificial light in their tens of thousands, fed unnatural diets and unable to carry out their natural behaviour was still a remote concept. However on 6 April 2007 a new law came into force: The Animal Welfare Act 2006.

The new Act enforces upon owners of pets a ‘duty of care’ and means that the new legislation can be used to stop the suffering of pet animals before it occurs. Previously a duty of care existed only for farm animals – pet owners couldn’t be prosecuted until suffering had already occurred. The new bill makes clear that owners of domestic animals have a legal duty to provide their pets with a suitable environment, adequate food and water and allow them to exhibit their natural behaviour. They are also legally bound to protect them from pain, suffering and injury. The welfare of farmed animals, on the other hand, is treated separately in the new Act under the Welfare of Farmed Animals (England) Regulations 2007. In broad terms the new directives restate that it’s an offence to cause unnecessary suffering to any farm animal. However the overwhelming majority of regulations in the 2007 act do nothing more than replicate those of the 1911 Act. In other words there is little change.

The preservation of the old regulations demonstrate monumental contradictions – both within the law and in practice – with regard to the welfare of pets on the one hand and factory farmed animals on the other.

While industrial farmed animals are fed profoundly unnatural diets so that they grow as quickly as possible, pampered pets are fed on ‘selected high-grade ingredients’ with ‘moist, tasty flavours’ ‘planned with their dietary needs in mind’ ‘pure as nature intended’. Nevertheless, however enticingly packaged, meat based pet food is made for the most part from ‘meat derivatives’. These ingredients – usually known as mechanically separated meat (MSM)) but also called mechanically recovered (MRM) or mechanically derived (MDM) – are slaughterhouse ‘by-products’, the remains of those parts of farmed animals that are not suitable for human consumption. Since the BSE epidemic, MSM from beef, sheep and goats is no longer permitted and ‘recovered’ meat now comes from pigs and poultry rendered into palatable form. MSM includes fat, gristle and bones; blood, feet, heads, lungs, liver, intestines; they can even contain beaks, feathers, hair and faeces. But whatever the contents they will, like all processed food, have gone through a thorough cooking process designed to eliminate bacteria and moulds and ensure a hygienic end product, appealingly presented. But whatever the origin, branded pet food has nevertheless been created to suit the animals’ nutritional needs, to ‘ensure a correct balance of proteins, fats and oils, minerals, vitamins, carbohydrates and water for optimal health’.

The diet of factory farmed animals on the other hand is designed to maximize production: they must put on weight in the shortest possible time and at minimum cost. High in protein and fat the ingredients are cheap and bear little relation to what the animals would eat in a natural environment. While fat might be derived from fish or palm kernels, protein might include feather meal – made from the feathers of slaughtered birds – and poultry by-product meal – the rendered left-overs from the meat industry including discarded male chicks and rejects from the egg industry.

The paradoxes and incongruities seem endless. While pets are fed their gourmet meals, amused with toys, pampered with grooming products and perhaps recline on beds fashioned in the most up-to-date style, farmed animals are bedded on wire or slats or on litter saturated with their own excrement. Crammed into vast, windowless sheds, animals farmed on an industrial scale have no space to express their natural behaviour other than to eat and drink. Their alien fast-fattening diet turns them into obese and grotesque images of their natural selves. Crippled, malformed and plagued with obesity-related diseases they suffer from fatty liver and kidney syndrome; from rickets and abnormal bone and muscle development; they are racked with leg weaknesses, lameness and joint diseases. Unnaturally rapid growth causes hearts to become enlarged and lungs congested; fluid builds up in the abdomen and the strain often results in heart failure – called ‘sudden death syndrome’ in the industry. Afflicted with infirmities, infections and disorders their lives are inherently unhealthy and diseased.

Meanwhile owners of ‘domestic animals’ can have legal action taken against them if they allow their pets to suffer from pain, suffering or injury. It seems a terrible irony that pet owners can be prosecuted for allowing an animal in their care to become overweight. To this end they might even indulge their pampered pets with life-style drugs. The most recent is a weight-loss drug for dogs because “…pet obesity…” in the words of the RSPCA “…is a serious animal welfare problem and as a nation of so-called animal lovers we have a duty to tackle it now.”

The inconsistencies persist. While nature lovers gather together to clean sea birds caught in oil slicks in an attempt to save them – and for which there is a Wildlife Careline – millions of ducks in factory farms have water dispensed from ‘nipple drinkers’, a sort of teat. Unable to dip even their heads in water these aquatic birds are unable to preen or bathe. This means they spend their entire 7-week lives with filthy curled and sticky feathers, with nostrils and eyes encrusted with food and dirt, overweight, crippled and diseased on a sodden bed of litter that is a combination of wood shavings, excreta, feathers, wasted feed and permeated with the stench of ammonia.

When two Tamworth Ginger pigs escaped from a slaughterhouse in Malmesbury animal sanctuaries were inundated with calls from people asking for them to be saved. Named Butch and Sundance the escapees were described in the media as ‘heroic'. A spokesman at an animal sanctuary said, “We would love to have this pair. We already have a refugee from the slaughterhouse, a bullock we called Braveheart, who swam a river to escape – just like the pigs.”

Nevertheless since the early days of factory farming there have been improvements. In the 1950s veal calves were kept in crates with lids on top (holes in the lids allowed them to breathe)in total darkness, in solitary confinement on slatted floors, tethered so tightly they could only stand up or lie down but never turn around. Fed solely on milk they were unable to satisfy the deficiencies in their diet and their craving for solid food. Filthy, blind, lonely, with swollen, painful joints and covered in flies they lived their 5 month lives in abject misery. The industry’s objective was to ensure calves were anaemic and their flesh white. After tens of years of campaigning by animal welfare organizations veal crates were finally banned in the UK in 1990. The EU followed suit in 2006. Although calves are no longer penned in solitary crates the conditions on most European veal farms are nevertheless still cramped and barren. Floors are often slatted – which make standing difficult – and although feed must now include some dietary fibre it’s usually less than the UK minimum.

Now, thanks to a number of welfare organisations, consumer demand and the Good Veal Campaign there is a market for rose veal. This pink veal is produced from calves which are reared in groups outside on pasture in summer or in light airy sheds with plenty of space and bedding in winter. Fed a varied diet the calves suffer none of the deprivations of their crated counterparts. Their pink firm flesh proves they have been reared on a healthy diet and given the freedom to exercise. But these are only small beginnings. Of the veal eaten in the UK only 5% is rose veal. The remaining 95% is imported from the continent where welfare standards for veal calves still fall far short of British standards.

The UK has also seen a decline in battery hens. While in the EU 85% of laying hens are kept in battery cages in the UK the percentage is 63%. 32% come from ‘free-range’ hens and the remaining 5% from hens in ‘barns’ or ‘percheries’. Some supermarkets no longer sell any boxed eggs from battery chickens and the other big supermarket chains seem to be shaping up to follow suit. Yet free-range eggs don’t always come from hens which are as free as the packaging implies. By law flock sizes can consist of 9,000 birds and critics of large flocks claim that when numbers are as large as this a majority of hens never find out that exits to their sheds even exist. But at least – unlike their caged counterparts – they are able to move around and behave a little more naturally. However of the eggs used in the UK catering and processing trades most are imported and most – 90% – are from caged hens.

To a certain extent the welfare of some pigs has improved too. Nowadays 30% of the UK’s breeding sows are kept in outdoor systems, a higher percentage than any other country in Europe. However most piglets born on outdoor units are removed from their mothers when they’re between 2 and 4 weeks old and ‘finished’ in densely crowded indoor systems until they’re slaughtered at 4 or 5 months for pork and 10 months for bacon.

But there have been retrograde steps too. Salmon farms have been called the new factory farms under the sea. With 70,000 fish to a pen and 15 kilos of fish to a cubic metre of water the amount of space for each fish is equivalent to a 60 centimetre salmon in a household bath. Trapped in cages they have no outlet for their natural migratory instincts and as they swim ceaselessly in circles they bully and attack each other. An environment like this is alien to fish that are by nature solitary, aggressive and genetically programmed to spend most of their lives swimming free and alone through the open ocean.

Quail have been described as factory farms’ smallest and most recent victims. These tiny fragile birds are by nature even more timid than chickens and like all poultry reared in industrial systems they too suffer from swollen joints and leg and foot problems; from diseases, stress and injuries; from swollen heads, nasal discharges and runny eyes caused by ammonia fumes.

The rabbit farming industry is also expanding as farmers, encouraged by farm diversification schemes, branch out. With 6–8 rabbits to a cage; cages 18 inches and high stacked in tiers ; a floor area 2 feet by 3 feet; the conditions in which they are reared are hardly different from those of battery hens. Rabbit farmers are advised to expect a general mortality rate of 25% and females a ‘uselife’ of 18 months.

But it’s not only physical cruelty that animals on factory farms have to endure. That animals can suffer psychologically is acknowledged by European Union law which recognizes farm animals as sentient beings or, in other words, as having the capacity to suffer.

Most animal experts agree that animals and humans share the same basic needs: food, safety, companionship and an emotionally normal life. Yet factory farmed animals are treated as industrial commodities. Every aspect of their lives is controlled. Their environment, their movement, their feeding. They never see the sun or smell fresh air or feel the grass beneath their feet. Hens have an overwhelming need to lay in privacy and pigs to defecate away from the group yet they are denied any seclusion or space to carry out their natural behaviours. They can’t form relationships with their young or each other. Even the way they mate is controlled. Brought into season with hormones and artificially inseminated, millions of animals never mate naturally. Lambs are often born during the bleakest winter months and, with the aid of hormones and selective breeding, ewes now give birth to 2 or 3 lambs. The natural number is one. Pigs give birth to litters of 11–15 piglets. The natural number is 5–6. Hens lay 300 eggs a year. The natural number is about 20. Dairy cows, ewes and sows are all kept in a perpetual cycles of pregnancy.

Keith Kendrick, professor of neurobiology at the Babraham Institute in Cambridge, sums up the expert’s view: “The assumption that farm animals cannot suffer from conditions that would be considered intolerable for humans is partly based on the idea they are less intelligent than people and have ‘no sense of self’. Increasingly, however, research reveals this to be untrue.”

What seems least acknowledged with regard to farm animals is that they are individuals with their own unique personalities and feelings. Some might be sensitive and gentle while others are boisterous, irritating or annoying; some crave affection; others are playful. No pet owner would deny that their pets have some of these characteristics.

In a natural environment farm animals, like humans, make strong bonds with each other and usually have a few chosen companions they like to spend most of their time with. But when they are densely crowded their natural behaviour is inhibited and stress and aggression takes its place. This means fear is added to their predicament especially if they’re smaller and weaker than others in their group. Cows kick into udders – injuries can be serious and in some cases teats torn off. Pigs bite at tails; between 3% and 5% of pigs in intensive systems die because of injuries to tails. Chickens, turkeys, guinea fowl and quail, with nothing to peck at other than their food and each other, pull at their cage-mates’ feathers. As a measure to reduce wounds these animals are de-beaked, de-horned, castrated, tail docked or teeth clipped. Animals in a natural environment never behave in the way animals in factory farms behave.

And while the system turns these animals into agricultural products the law works to satisfy relentless consumer demand and ensure that farmed animals are bred, reared and despatched as quickly as possible.

Instead of the duty of care set down in law which requires that those who are responsible for farmed animals should make sure they are safe and protected from harm, the reality is quite different. With one farm worker to look after tens of thousands of animals attentive vigilant management is not a feasible option and neither is it part of a factory farm’s business strategy.


BIBLIOGRAPHY

‘Abattoir based DIY training is best’, Farmers Weekly, 12.09.1997

Advocates for Animals, www.advocatesforanimals.org.uk

Advocates for Animals, ‘Pain Reality, Why painful mutilations of animals must be reviewed’, 2006

AGRA CEAS report for the RSPCA, ‘Everyone’s a winner’. How rearing chickens to higher welfare standards can benefit the chicken, producer, retailer and consumer

AGRA CEAS info@ceasc.com

Agricultural and Food Research Council (replaced 1994 by Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council) (BBSRC)

Animal Aid, www.animalaid.org.uk

Animal Aid, ‘From Shell to Hell: the modern egg industry’, Gregory N G and Wilkins L J, 1989

Animal Aid, ‘The Killing Fields’, September 2000

Animal Aid, ‘A law unto themselves – the game shooting industry under the spotlight (part 2) The burial pits’

Animal Ethics Encyclopaedia

Animal Sentience Website, www.animalsentience.com

Animal Welfare Act 2006, www.defra.gov.uk

Animal Welfare: ‘Codes of recommendations for the welfare of livestock – Deer’, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, www.defra.gov.uk

Animal Welfare: ‘Codes of recommendations for the welfare of livestock – Turkeys’, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs

Animal Welfare Group, www.cawg.org.uk

Annex B: ‘Market Analysis for Key Sectors’, Defra

Atema, Jelle; Steinbach, Molly A, ‘Chemical Communication and Social Behaviour of the Lobster Homarus americanus and Other Decapod Crustacea’, Oxford Scholarship Online Monographs, 2007

Aucott, Lorna, ‘Doing the job properly, The challenge of farming organic poultry’, Organic Research Centre, 2007

Baker, Barbara Safeway, ‘Outdoor bred pork’, www.racetothetop.org

Baker, Dr John R, (oxon) FRCS, ‘The Humane Killing of Lobsters and Crabs’, The Humane Education Centre, Australia, 1975 (The Shellfish Network)

Baker, Roger, ‘Export of Live Cattle – Fact and Perception’, Conservative Animal Welfare Group, www.cawg.org.uk

Barnett, Antony, ‘Scandal of factory farmed pheasants’, The Observer, Sunday June 27 2004

BBC Radio 4 Today, Video, ‘Training to Boost Fish Survival’,

5 October 2001

Bekoff, Marc, Consciousness and Self in Animals: Some Reflections, Beck Beckoff, Zygon Volume 38, Number 2, June 2003, Blackwell Publishing

Benn, Joanna, ‘Norway-the rising tide of fish farming’, 19 Nov 2003, www.peopleandplanet.net

Bird, Nick, ‘Pig Lighting’, Farmex, www.farmex.co.uk

Blythman, Joanna, The Food We Eat, Fourth Estate, 2006

Blythman, Joanna, ‘Why organic salmon is causing a nasty smell’, Guardian Unlimited, Sunday October 22, 2006, environment www.guardian.co.uk

Bortolotti, Lisa Dr, ‘Stem cell research, personhood (sic) and sentience’, Ethics, Law and Moral Philosophy of Reproductive Biomedicine, vol 1, 1 March 2005

Braithwaite V A and Salvenes AG, ‘Scientists hatch plan to help farmed cod restock North Sea’; Research Newsletter, Vol. 2, October 2005, University of Edinburgh, School of Biological Sciences

Brattelid, T & Smith A J, Laboratory Animals (2000) www.lal.org.uk/fish

British Association for Shooting and Conservation www.basc.org.uk

British Marine Finfish Association, www.bmfa.uk.com

British Poultry Council, ‘Chicken farm disappointed by RSPCA’s confused campaign’, May 7, 2004, www.thepoultrysite.com, British Veterinary Poultry Association, www.bvpa.org.uk

Bristol University School of Veterinary Science, www.vetschool.bris.ac.uk

British Veterinary Association: Animal Welfare Foundation www.bva-awfco.uk

Brown Calum, Laland Kevin & Krause Jens (Eds), Fish Cognition and Behaviour, Blackwell Publishing, 2006

Browne, Anthony, ‘Ten weeks to live’, Observer Food Monthly, Sunday March 10, 2002

Broom, Donald (quote) ‘Fish Feel Pain’, www.fishinghurts.com/FishFeelPain

Bruce, A, ‘The Commercial Egg Industry should consider controlled atmosphere stunning of spent laying hens’, 2007, www.thepoultrysite.com/articles

‘Bycatch’, Greenpeace International, www.greenpeace.org/usa/campaigns/oceans/threats/bycatch

Caithness Community www.caithness.org

Cambac Associates, www.stotfoldpigs.co.uk

‘Campaigners want polluted salmon farm endorsed by Oliver to be shut’, The Independent, March 2005

Canning, Philip, ‘The UK Game Bird Industry – A Short Study’, prepared for Defra, 2005, www.adas.co.uk

Canterbury Animal Respect Network for a Green Environment,Community Website, www.carn-age.org.uk

Canterbury Animal Respect Network for a Green Environment, www.carn-age.org.uk

‘Cetacean Bycatch and Pelagic Trawling’, July 2005, www.greenpeace.org.uk/media/reports/cetacean-bycatch-and-pelagic-trawling

Chambers, John, ‘Optimising the environment in which pigs are reared’,

Chandroo KP, Duncan IJH, Moccia RD, ‘Can Fish Suffer? Perspectives On Sentience, Pain, Fear And Stress’, www.thefishsite.com

Clarke, Bernadette, ‘Good fish guide’, Marine Conservation Society, 2002

Clarke, Matt, ‘Blind cave fish are smarter than dogs’, Practical Fish Keeping magazine, October 4, 2004

Clover, Charles, The End of the Line, Ebury Press, 2004

Cockerill, Dave, ‘Using X-ray to visualise skeletal deformities’, the Fish Vet Group, July 2005, The Fish Site, www.thefishsite.com

Code of Recommendations for the Welfare of Livestock: laying hens, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs

Code of Recommendations for the Welfare of Livestock: Meat Chickens and Breeding Chickens, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs

Code of Recommendations for the Welfare of Livestock: Sheep, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs

Code of Recommendations for the Welfare of Livestock: Turkeys, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs

Communicable Disease Surveillance Centre, www.cdscni.org.uk

Compassion in World Farming Trust, www.ciwf.org.uk

Compassion in World Farming Trust, ‘Stop-Look-Listen Recognising the Sentience of Farm Animals’, 2006

Compassion in World Farming, letter to Christopher Elmer, Defra, on Council Regulation (EC) No 1/2005 on the protection of animals during transport and related operations, www.ciwf.org.uk

Compassion in World Farming Trust, ‘The BSE Inquiry: The Report 2005 Consultation on lifting the export ban. Comments on Export’, www.ciwf.org.uk

Compassion in World Farming Trust, ‘Welfare of Animals (Transport) Order’, 1997

Conservative Animal Welfare Group

Council Regulation (EC) No 1/2005 on the protection of animals during transport and related operations, www.ciwf.org.uk

Council of Europe, Recommendations Concerning Muscovy and Domestic Ducks, Article 2 (h)

Council of Europe, 1995 Draft Recommendation Concerning Pheasants

Country Smallholding, www.countrysmallholding.com

‘Crafty sheep conquer cattle grids’, 30 July 2004, BBC News Channel

Crichton, Peter, ‘Outdoor pigs rooting out profit’, Farmers Weekly Interactive, September 6 2005

Croft, Dr Darren ‘Investigating the Social Organisation of Animal Societies’, Behavioural Ecology Library, biology www.bangor.ac.uk

Cummins, Rachel, ‘The truth about free range poultry and eggs’, www.goodfoodpages.co.uk, April 2006

Dairy fact file, ‘Good for your wealth?’ www.animalaid.org.uk

Davis, Chris, ‘To bit or not to bit?’, The Game Conservancy Trust Review of 2004, www.gct.org.uk

Dawkins, Marian Stamp, Through Our Eyes Only?, Oxford University Press 1998

Defra investigates egg labelling fraud, Defra news release, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, March 2007

DeLaval, Dairy Knowledge, ‘Efficient Herd Management’, www.delaval.co.uk

Defra (Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs) Guidelines, ‘Responsible use of vaccines and vaccination in poultry production’, November 2006

Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, www.defra.gov.uk

Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs ‘Use of Animal Blood in Animal Feed’, September 2000, www.food.gov.uk

Department for Food, Environment and Rural Affairs, ‘Code of Recommendations for Laying Hens’, 2002, www.defra.gov.uk

Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, ‘Animal Welfare: Codes of Recommendations for the Welfare of Livestock’, www.defra.gov.uk

Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, England Implementation Group, Assurance Schemes, www.defra.gov.uk

Disease factsheet, Defra

‘Diet, nutrition and the prevention of chronic disease’, Report of a Joint WHO/FAO expert consultation, Technical Report Series 916 Geneva 2003, ISBN 924120916X

‘Doctors add their voice to farmers’ call for action over OP sheep dips’, Becky Allen and Peter Beaumont, Report for the National Farmers Union and the British Medical Associations joint seminar, 1995

‘Doing the job properly, The challenge of farming organic poultry’, Organic Research Centre, 2007

‘Dolphin Alert’, Deborah Rephan, Greenpeace Foundation, GPUSA Statement, 19 April 1999, www.greenpeacefoundation.com/dolphinrose.html

Druce, Clare, Director of Farm Animal Network, ‘Rearing Pheasants for Shoots’, www.animalaid.co.uk

Duncan I J, Slee G S, Seawright E, Breward J, ‘Behavioural consequences of partial beak amputation (beak trimming) in poultry’, AFRC Institute of Animal Physiology and Genetics Research, Edinburgh Research Station, Roslin, Midlothian, Scotland

Dunn, Norman, ‘Searching for the ‘gentle’ hen’, Norman, World Poultry vol 2 No 6 2005 www.agriworld.co.uk

Egg Production, NFU, www.nfuonline.com

Elliott, Valerie, ‘Egg mastermind duped shoppers with 500 million ‘free-range’ fakes’, The Times, March 19 2007

Ethics & Suffering – Sentience and Cognition 2005, www.fishwelfare.net

Encylopaedia Britannica 2002

England Implementation Group, Assurance Schemes, www.defra.gov.uk

Environmental Benefits of Growth-Promoting Antibiotics, NOAH, National Office of Animal Health for the welfare of animals, 2004

‘Environmentalists Alarmed Over Giant GM Fish’, Reuters Online Service, 11 April 200

EU Scientific Report Support Calls for Legal Protection for Lobsters, Crabs and Octopuses, 10 January 2006, www.advocatesforanimals.org.uk

Executive Summary, Report on Legal Remedies in Relation to Sea Trout Protection and Salmon

Extraordinary Animals, the smartest pig, throng, www.tvthrong.co.uk

Facatico, Anne, ‘Sustainable Poultry: Production Overview – Part II’, www.thepoultrysite.com

Farm Animal Welfare Council, www.fawc.org.uk

Farm Animal Welfare Council Report, Welfare of broiler breeds

Farm Animal Welfare Council, Report on Farm Animal Welfare: ‘The Case for Welfare Labelling’, June 2006, the Fish Site www.thefishsite.com

Farm Animal Welfare Council Report, Welfare of dairy cattle

Farm Animal Welfare Council Report, Welfare of farmed fish

Farm Animal Welfare Council Report, Infra Rd Beak Treatment

Farm Animal Welfare Council Report, Welfare Implications of Castration and Tail Docking, June 2008

Farm Animal Welfare Council Report, Welfare of turkeys

Farm Animal Welfare Network, www.fawn.me.uk

Farmers Weekly Interactive, www.fwi.co.uk

Farming Friends, www.farmingfriends.com

Farming Today, This Week, BBC Radio 4, Saturday 9 August 2008

Fearnley-Whittingstall, Hugh, The River Cottage Cook Book, Hodder & Stoughton, 2004

Fisheries Research Service, Marine Laboratory, www.frsscotland.gov.uk www.fishonline.org

Fiskeriforskning, ‘Preventing Disease in Farmed Cod’, March 2006, www.thefishsite.com

Fishmeal Information Network, UN Food and Agricultural Organisation (FAO) and International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)

Fletchers of Auchtermuchty, www.seriouslygoodvenison.co.uk

Flintoff Jean-Paul, ‘Look deep into their eyes…’ The Sunday Times, 24.August 2008

Frantzen, Jan Fredrik, Fiskeriforskning, ‘Will Fight New Cod Disease’, 24 August 2006

Game Farmers Association, GFA Code of Practice, 2006, www.gfa.org.uk/gfa-code-of-practice

Game Farmers Association, www.gfa.org.uk

Gas Killing of Chicks in Hatcheries, The Humane Slaughter Association, 2006

Gellatley, Juliet, ‘Ducks out of Water’, revised 2006, www.viva.org.uk

Goddard, Pete, ‘The welfare of deer during transport and prior to slaughter’, www.macaulay.ac.uk

Gold, Mike, ‘The Global Benefits of Eating Less Meat’, A Report for the Compassion in World Farming Trust, 2004

Grandin, Dr Temple, Animals Are Not Things, A View on Animal Welfare Based on Neurological Complexity, www.grandin.com/welfare/animals.are.not.things.html

Grandin, Temple and Johnson Catherine, Animals in Translation Using the Mysteries of Autism to Decode Animal Behaviour, Bloomsbury, 2005

Greenpeace, www.greenpeace.org.uk

‘Greenpeace continues to disrupt North Sea cod fishing’, 14 May 2007, www.greenpeace.org.uk/media/press-releases/greenpeace-continues-to-disrupt-north-sea-cod-fishing-20070514

Gregory N G and Wilkins L J, ‘Broken Bones in Chickens: effects of stunning and processing in broilers’, British Poultry Science 31:33–38

Griffin, Donald R, Animal Minds, Beyond Cognition to Consciousness, University of Chicago Press, 2001

Grigson, Sophie and Black, William, Organic: A new way of eating, Headline Book Publishing 2001

Guidelines for Avoiding Cruelty in Shellfish Preparation, New South Wales Agriculture, Animal Welfare Unit, 1994

Guidelines on semen collection by electroejaculation in relation to the examination of rams for breeding, www.ingentaconnect.com

Hamilton. R, National Geographic 2004 ‘Beautiful and Beastly Squid’

Hasting, Max, ‘We need to care about the fish or there won’t be any left to eat’, The Guardian, October 31, 2005

Hay M, Rue J, Sansac C, Brunel G and Prunier A, Animal Welfare 2004, Vol 13: 27-32, ‘Long-term detrimental effects of tooth clipping or grinding in piglets: a histological approach’

Held S.; Mendl M.; Devereux C.; Byrne R.W. ‘Social tactics of pigs in a competitive foraging task: the ‘informed forager’ paradigm’, Animal Behaviour, Volume 59, Number 3, March 2000, pp. 569-576(8)

Hickman, Martine, ‘The ethics of eating: the appeal of veal’, The Independent, September 2, 2006

Hillman, Harold, Mb Bsc PhD, ‘The Slaughter of Animals for Food’, www.hedweb.com

Hillman, Mark, ‘All is not well down on the dairy farm’, The Independent, 7 November, 2005

HSUS report, ‘The Welfare of Animals in the Turkey Industry’, www.hsus.org/farm resources/welfare-turkeys html

Home Office (1989) code of Practice for the Housing and Care of Animals Used in Scientific Research, www.greenpeace.org.uk

House of Lords Debates, www.theyworkforyou.com/lords

Hovi, Malla, Animal Health and Welfare in Organic Livestock Production, State Vet Journal, 2003, www.defra.gov.uk

Howells et al, ‘Influence of the number of days spent in training in an abattoir on the efficiency of do-it-yourself artificial insemination’, Veterinary Record 144, 310-314, 1999

Huxley JN et al, ‘Animal-based welfare assessments: benchmarking as a tool for health and welfare planning in organic dairy herds’ Final Draft of a paper published in the Veterinary Record August 21, 2004

‘In God’s Name – Religious Slaughter’, a report for Viva!

Johnson Sustainable Seafoods, Shetland

Kendrick, Keith, ‘Through a Sheep’s Eye’, New Scientist, Issue 1716, 12 May 1990

Kendrick, Keith Professor of neurobiology at the Babraham Institute in Cambridge

Kestin SC et al, ‘Protocol for assessing brain function in fish and the effectiveness of methods used to stun and kill them’, Veterinary Record, 2002 Vol.150 www.nafc.ac.uk

Killing Fish for Human Consumption, www.shellfishnetwork.org.uk

Kirkby, Alex, ‘Waste was fed to UK cattle’, 27 October 1999, BBC News Sci/Tech

Knowles T G and Broom D M, ‘Limb and bone strength and movement in laying hens from different housing systems, Veterinary Record, 126 p. 354–356, 1990

Knowles T G et al, ‘The effects of stocking density during the road transport of lambs’, Veterinary Record, No 142, p 503–509

Kurlansky, Mark, A Biography of the Fish that Changed the World, Vintage, 1999

Laboratory birds: refinements in husbandry and procedures, Fifth report of the BVAAWF/FRAME/RSPCA/UFAW Joint Working Group on Refinement, Hawkins, Dr Penny (Editor) Laboratory Animals (2001) 35 (Suppl. 1), The Royal Society of Medicine Press

Lameness in sheep, quote from Royal Veterinary College, Defra

Laurence, Felicity, Eat Your Heart Out: Why the Food Business Is Bad for the Planet and Your Health, Penguin, 2008

League Against Cruel Sports, www.league.org.uk

Leake, Jonathan, ‘The Secret Life of Moody Cows’, The Sunday Times, February 27, 2005, www.timesonline.co.uk

Lion Quality, British Egg Information Service, www.britegg.co.uk

Lymbery, Philip, In Too Deep, A Report for Compassion in World Farming Trust, February 2001, www.ciwf.org.uk

Manning AN and MS Dawkins, An Introduction to Animal Behaviour (Fifth Edition), Cambridge University Press, 1998, Earthscan Publications Ltd ISBN 185 383 6729

Marchant-Forde, Jeremy N & Marchant-Forde, Ruth, Minimizing inter-pig aggression during mixing, CABI Publishing, USA

Marine Conservation Society, www.mcsuk.org

McFarland, David, Animal Behaviour, Psychobiology, Ethology and Evolution Third Edition, Longman, 1999

Meat and Livestock Commission, (now BPEX English Pig Sector Ltd), www.bpex.org.uk

Meat Promotion Wales, Keeping Lambs Alive. www.hybucoqcymru.org

Meeker, David (Ed), ‘Essential Rendering, All About the Animal Byproducts Industry’, www.renderers.org

Miles RD and Chapman FA, ‘The Benefits of Fish Meal in Aquaculture Diets’, University of Florida, July 2006

Mollusc Purification and Advisory Service, Industry Guidelines in collaboration with the Trade, Local Food Authorities and relevant Government Departments

Montaigne, Fen, National Geographic 2003 ‘Atlantic Salmon’

Moorland Scotland, Facts & Figures, ‘Grouse Shooting on Scottish Moorlands’, 2008

Moore, Rebecca, ‘Good or Bad Milk’, 2003

Murry, K, ‘Changing Patterns of Lamb Distribution From Farm to Abattoir’, Sheep Veterinary Society 1999

NADIS, Facial Necrosis, Pig Health, NADIS, Pig Health, May 2008

NADIS, Pig Health Report October 2007, www.stackyard.com

National Sheep Association, www.nationalsheep.org.uk

Northern Ireland Pesticide Sage Survey Report, www.afbnini.gov.uk

League Against Cruel Sports, Submission to the Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee, December 2005

O’Brien, Dr Tim, ‘Factory Farming and Human Health, A Compassion World Farming Trust Report’, 1997, www.ciwf.org.uk/campaigns/other_campaigns/exotic_foods.html

O’Connell, Sanjida, ‘Why farmed ducks endure worse conditions than battery hens’, The Independent, 06 July 2006

OF&G Section 12, Standards for the Slaughter of Farmed Livestock (including poultry), www.organicfarmer.org.uk

Oliver, Jamie, The Naked Chef, Penguin Books, 1999

Organic Farmers &Growers, Section 12, Standards for the Slaughter of Farmed Livestock (including poultry), www.organicfarmer.org.uk

Organic Poultry Standards, www.organic-vet.reading.ac.uk

Organic Studies Centre www.organicstudiescornwall.co.uk

‘Pain reality. Why painful mutilations must be reviewed’, Advocates for Animals, www.advocatesforanimals.co.uk

Pane, Gilly, Information Sheet: Pigs, The Vegetarian Society

PETA UK: People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, www.peta.org.uk

Pennycott, Tom, Welfare concerns in game bird rearing, SAC, www.bva-awf.org.uk

Pheasant is often regarded as a “natural” meat. however, the modern pheasant is likely to have been reared semi- intensively and to have suffered serious welfare insults, Farm Animal Welfare Network, www.fawn.me.uk

Picket, Heather, Industrial Animal Agriculture, report for Compassion in World Farming Trust, 2003

Preisenger, Rudolf and Flock, Dietmar K., ‘Genetic changes in layer breeding: Historical trends and future prospects’, bsas.org.uk

Purvis, Andrew, ‘Farmed Fish’, Guardian Unlimited, Sunday May 11, 2003, www.guardian.co.uk

Purvis, Andrew, ‘Pecking Order’, Guardian Unlimited, Sunday September 24,2006, www.guardian.co.uk

Quality Meats Scotland Meeting your Customers’ Flavour Needs www.chefsguidetoscotchbeef.org/plate/flavour-needs.html

Quill Productions, Gamebirds, www.quillproductions.co.uk/gamebirds.html

‘Race to the Top, Tracking supermarket progress towards a greener and fairer food system’, www.racetothetop.org

Raised Gamebird Laying Unit, The Policy of the Game Farmers’ Association www.gfa.org.uk

‘Raising the Standard’ CIWF survey 2005–2006

Randall, Maurice and Bolla, Gerry, ‘Raising Japanese Quail’, 2006, www.thepoultrysite.com

Red Meat Industry Forum, www.redmeatindustryforum.org.uk

‘Rendered Animal Products for Swine’, www.renderers.org

Report on the Welfare of Farmed Animals at Slaughter and Killing, Farm Animal Welfare Council, 2003

Report and Recommendations of a Workshop, organized by the Humane slaughter Association, on the Transport of Livestock for Market and Slaughter post FMD, www.hsa.org.uk

Respect for Quarry Code of Practice (revised August 2007), British Association for Shooting and Conservation, www.basc.org.uk/content/respect_for_quarry_code

Ridley M. Animal Behaviour (Second Edition), Blackwell Scientific Publications, 1995

Rose, Dr Naomi, Dr Human Society of the US, www.hsus.org

Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, www.rspca.org

Royal Society for the Protection of Birds www.RSPB.org.uk

Royal Overseas League, lecture, Dr Yunes Teinaz

RSPCA ‘Animal Breeding – Domestication’, www.rspcaeducation.org

RSPCA Freedom Food, www.rspca.org.uk

RSPCA Members Watchdog No 72, www.webtribe.net

SAC, Scottish Agricultural College, www.sac.ac.uk

Saides, Sylvia, ‘The Cow Whisperer’, www.the-scientist.com

Salvenes, Anne Gro and Braithwaite, Victoria, ‘The need to understand the behaviour of fish reared for mariculture or restocking’, ICES Journal of Marine Science, 2006

Sandeem A I, Braasted BO, Boe KE, ‘Eye white may indicate emotional state on a frustration-contentedness axis in dairy cows, Applied Animal Behaviour Science, Volume 79, No 1, Elesevier 20 September 2002, pp 1–10, Agricultural University of Norway

Sheep Newsletter, Endell Veterinary Group, www.endellveterinarygroup.co.uk

Shetland Salmon Farming Industry Code of Best Practice, www.scotland.gov.uk

Shooting Facts, The Economic and Environmental Impact of Sporting Shooting, report prepared by PACEC on behalf of the British Association for Shooting and Conservation, Country Land and Business Association, and Countryside Alliance and in association with Game Conservancy Trust, 2006

Smith, Jane A, A Question of Pain in Invertebrates, www.shellfishnetwork.org.uk

Smith, Rebecca, ‘Sentenced to Death’, A Viva! report on the slaughter of farmed animals in the UK, Part Four: Cattle Slaughter, www.viva.org.uk

Soil Association, www.soilassociation.org

Soil Association, Consumer Guide

Soil Association Standards are different www.soilassoc.org/web/saweb.nst

Soil Association organic standards Revision 15 April 2005

Spongiform Encephalopathy Advisory Committee, www.seac.gov.uk

Spongiform Encephalopathy Advisory Committee Minutes of the 19th SEAC meeting 21 June 1995), paragraph 15.

Stereotypic Animal Behaviour, edited by Mason G and Rushen G, Oxford University Press, 2007

Stevenson, Peter, Animal Welfare Problems in UK Slaughterhouses, A Report by the Compassion in World Farming Trust, July 2001

Sustain: the alliance for better food and farming, www.sustainweb.org.uk

Swarbrick, O, ‘Pheasant rearing: associated husbandry & disease problems’, Veterinary Record, Vol. 116, Issue 23, 610-617

Taylor A A et al, ‘Behavioural responses of piglets to castration: the effect of piglet age’, Elsevier, Applied Animal Behaviour Science, Vol 73, Issue 1, p 35-43,D01 10.1016/S0168-1591(01)00123-

Teinaz, Yunes, Dr, ‘Meat Crimes in the UK’, Lecture to the Royal Overseas League, 19 May 2004

The Atlantic Salmon Trust, www.atlanticsalmontrust.org

The BSE Inquiry: The Report 2005 Consultation on lifting the export ban. Comments on Export, CIWF www.CIWF.org.uk

The end of antibiotic growth promoters: Some Questions & Answers, Briefing Document No 16, NOAH, National Office of Animal Health

The Fishing Industry: The Greatest Animal Welfare Industry Of Our Time?, www.animalaid.org.uk

The Game Conservancy Trust, www.gct.org.uk

The Grain and Trade Association. www.dafta.gov.uk

The Great Game Hoax, How battery Farms and GM Food Fuel the UK’s ‘Wild’ Game Meat Boom, League Against Cruel Sports

The Humane Slaughter Association www.hsa.org.uk

The Humane Society of the United States, www.wildlifeinformation.org

The Lobster Conservancy, www.lobsters.org

The Pig Site www.thepigsite.co.uk

The Poultry Site, www.thepoultrysite.com

The Salmon Farm Monitor, www.salmonfarmmonitor.org

The Shellfish Network, www.shellfishnetwork.org.uk

The Sunday Times, ‘Will organic farming restore faith in cod?’ The Sunday Times Scotland, June 04, 2006, www.timesonline.co.uk

The use of Mixtures of the Gases CO2, O2, and N2 for Stunning or Killing Poultry, Report of the Scientific Committee on animal Health and Animal Welfare, adopted 23rd June 1998

The Vegetarian Society, www.vegsoc.org

The Welfare of Pigs, Cattle and Sheep for Slaughter, The Compassion in World Farming Trust 2004

The Welfare of Fish and all Aquatic Invertebrates, various articles, www.pisces.demon.uk

Tinbergen N, Social Behaviour in Animals, (First Edition) Chapman and Hall, 1953

Trading Standards Lead the Way for Healthier Animals and Better Food (Gainsford, Ron, speech at annual conference June 2007) www.lacors.gov.uk/lacors/PressReleaseDetails

TSE Regulation 999/2001, Annex IV, (blood products and bloodmeal)

TSE amendment to 999/2001, Annex IV, (non-ruminant-derived blood products)

Turner, Clare and Sage, Rufus, ‘Released pheasant fate’, The Game and Wildlife Conservation Trust, www.gtc.org.uk

Turner, Jackie, ‘Silent Lambs, Sheep Welfare in Scotland’, Advocates for Animals, 2004, www.advocatesforanimals.org.uk

Turner, Jackie, STOP-LOOK-LISTEN Recognising the Sentience of Farm Animals updated version 2006

Turner, Jackie, ‘The Challenge of Animal Sentience’, Compassion in World Farming Trust, 2006, www.ciwf.org.uk

Turner, Dr Jacky and Lymbery, Philip ‘Brittle Bones: Osteoporosis and the Battery Cage’, A report for Compassion in World Farming January 1999

Turton, Sue, ‘Is organic milk ethical’, 3 October 2007, Channel 4 News www.channel4/com/news/articles/society

Tyler, Andrew, ‘The Silence of the Lambs’, An Animal Aid Report prepared as part of Animal Aid’s campaign to end abuses in sheep husbandry, New Renaiss'ance Magazine, Vol.5, No.2

Tyler Andrew, Kit Davidson and Anderson Chris, Assault and Battery, the nightmare existence of egg-producing ‘game birds’, www.animalaid.org.uk

UK Agriculture farming statistics, www.ukagriculture.com

‘UK Calf Transport and Veal Rearing’, Claire Weeks, Compassion in World Farming Trust, 2007

USDA Foreign Agricultural Service, New EC Proposal on Animal Welfare for Farmed Fish, 2005, www.thefishsite.com

Universities Federation for Animal Welfare Press Release – The Downside of Cutting Piglets’ Teeth, 2004

USDA/APHIS Guidelines for the Land Transport Of Fish, www.thefishsite.com

‘Use of Animal Blood in Animal Feed’, September 2000 www.food.gov.uk

Utilisation of egg shell waste from UK processing and hatchery establishments, ADAS for the report Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, May 2002

Ungoed-Thomas, Jon, ‘Shoppers in organic bird ‘con’, The Sunday Times, 18 2007

UKASTA, United Kingdom Agricultural Supply Trade Association, www.ukasta.org.uk

Vegan Society, www.vegansociety.org

Vegetarian Society, www.vegsoc.org

Veggies Catering Campaign, www.veggies.org.uk

Vet on the web, ‘Diseases of Pheasants’, www.vetontheweb.co.uk

Vernelli Toni, ‘The Dark Side of Dairy’, a report on the UK Dairy Industry, www.milkmyths.org.uk

Vestergaard K S, ‘Motivation to dust-bathe of laying hens housed in cages and aviaries’

Viva! Vegetarians International Voice for Animals, www.viva.org.uk

Walden, John, ‘The Atlantic Cod: the Potential for Farming in Scotland Information Note 3’, North Atlantic Fisheries college, Fisheries Training Centre Trust,

Wathes, C M, Farm Animal Welfare Council, Report on Welfare Labelling, June 2006, www.fawc.org.uk

Welfare Standard For Pigs Kept Outdoors, Soil Asscociation, 2007

Whiteman, Katie, The fish & shellfish kitchen handbook, Southwater 2003

Webster, John, A Cool Eye Towards Eden, Blackwell Sci. 1995

Webster, John, Limping Towards Eden, Blackwell, 2005

Welfare of Animals During Transport, 2008, www.Defra.gov.uk/animal/welfare/farmed/transport

Welfare of Farmed Animals (England) Regulations 2007 (S.I. 2007 No.2078

White, Mark, ‘Pig Disease Focus’, October 2007, report for NADIS

Worms and Worming in Poultry, Game Birds & Waterfowl, Pet Street, www.petstreet.co.uk/factsheet

World Society for the Protection of Animals (WSPA) www.wspafarmwelfare.org/hhnutrition.html

www.animalaid.org.uk

www.britishtrout.co.uk

www.burne-pet-nutrition.co.uk/Articles/understanding_pet_food_labels

www.ciwf.org.uk

www.defra.gov.uk

www.greenpeace.org.uk

www.liveexportcare.com

www.lobsterlib.com

www.organic.aber.ac.uk/statistics/europe

www.pisces.demon.uk

www.thedairysite.com

www.thefishsite.com

www.sac.ac.uk

www.vegsoc.or.uk

www.vet.ed.ac.uk/animalwelfare

www.warmwell.com/dirtymeat.html

www.wildlife1.wildlifeinformation.org

Young, Richard & Craig, Andrew, ‘Use and misuse of antibiotics in UK Agriculture, part 3: ‘Too hard to swallow – the truth about drugs and poultry’, report for the Soil Association, 2001



Comments via email would be appreciated:   onthemenu-animalwelfare

Daub